S MathiesonvsWalsall
Analysis based on 14 matches since 2000
* Note: Detailed card statistics for matches before 2005 may be incomplete.
When S Mathieson officiates Walsall matches, the statistics reveal a severe negative pattern. Based on 14 matches spanning multiple seasons, our comprehensive analysis shows Walsall achieves a 14.3% win rate under S Mathieson, compared to the 45% baseline expected for teams at this level. This negative 30.7 percentage point difference suggests a meaningful pattern worth examining. The data includes detailed card statistics, match outcomes, and historical trends to provide football fans, bettors, and analysts with evidence-based insights into this referee-team dynamic.
🚨 STRONG BIAS DETECTED
This referee has a significantly negative history with this team. Win rate is severely below average.
Notable Negative Pattern
With a bias score of -30.7%, this ranks among the more significant negative patterns in our database. Over 14 matches, Walsall has won 31 percentage points fewer games than expected. For bettors and fantasy managers, this historical trend suggests extra caution when S Mathieson is appointed.
The Bias Meter™
Match History
14 matches under this referee
| Date | Opponent | Score | Result | Cards | Division |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 27 Sept 2014 | Doncaster(H) | 3 - 0 | WIN | Walsall: 🟨 1 Doncaster: 🟨 2 | League One |
| 5 Nov 2011 | Huddersfield(A) | 1 - 1 | DRAW | Walsall: 🟨 1 Huddersfield: 🟨 1 | League One |
| 7 Aug 2010 | Milton Keynes Dons(H) | 1 - 2 | LOSS | Walsall: 🟨 1 Milton Keynes Dons: — | League One |
| 19 Dec 2009 | Leyton Orient(H) | 2 - 2 | DRAW | Walsall: 🟨 1 Leyton Orient: 🟨 1 | League One |
| 4 Oct 2008 | Hereford(A) | 0 - 0 | DRAW | Walsall: 🟨 1 Hereford: — | League One |
| 8 Dec 2007 | Crewe(A) | 0 - 0 | DRAW | Walsall: 🟨 1 Crewe: — | League One |
| 3 Mar 2007 | Darlington(A) | 0 - 0 | DRAW | Walsall: 🟨 1 Darlington: 🟨 1 | League Two |
| 28 Dec 2005 | Bradford(A) | 0 - 2 | LOSS | Walsall: 🟨 1 Bradford: 🟨 2 | League One |
| 1 Oct 2005 | Port Vale(A) | 2 - 3 | LOSS | Walsall: 🟨 1 Port Vale: 🟨 1 | League One |
| 2 Oct 2004 | Huddersfield(A) | 1 - 3 | LOSS | Walsall: 🟨 2 Huddersfield: — | League One |
| 20 Dec 2003 | West Ham(H) | 1 - 1 | DRAW | Walsall: 🟨 1 West Ham: —🟥 1 | Championship |
| 5 Apr 2003 | Portsmouth(H) | 1 - 2 | LOSS | Walsall: — Portsmouth: 🟨 1 | Championship |
| 1 Jan 2002 | Norwich(A) | 1 - 1 | DRAW | Walsall: 🟨 1 Norwich: 🟨 1 | Championship |
| 23 Oct 2001 | Rotherham(H) | 3 - 2 | WIN | Walsall: 🟨 2 Rotherham: 🟨 4 | Championship |
When S Mathieson officiates Walsall matches, the statistics reveal a severe negative pattern. Based on 14 matches spanning multiple seasons, our comprehensive analysis shows Walsall achieves a 14.3% win rate under S Mathieson, compared to the 45% baseline expected for teams at this level. This negative 30.7 percentage point difference suggests a meaningful pattern worth examining. The data includes detailed card statistics, match outcomes, and historical trends to provide football fans, bettors, and analysts with evidence-based insights into this referee-team dynamic.
Frequently Asked Questions
Detailed Statistics
Cards for Walsall
Cards for Opponents
Share This Analysis
Think your mates need to see this? Share the evidence.