S MathervsCarlisle
Analysis based on 8 matches since 2000
* Note: Detailed card statistics for matches before 2005 may be incomplete.
When S Mather officiates Carlisle matches, the statistics reveal a severe negative pattern. Based on 8 matches spanning multiple seasons, our comprehensive analysis shows Carlisle achieves a 25% win rate under S Mather, compared to the 45% baseline expected for teams at this level. This negative 20.0 percentage point difference suggests a meaningful pattern worth examining. The data includes detailed card statistics, match outcomes, and historical trends to provide football fans, bettors, and analysts with evidence-based insights into this referee-team dynamic.
🚨 STRONG BIAS DETECTED
This referee has a significantly negative history with this team. Win rate is severely below average.
Notable Negative Pattern
With a bias score of -20.0%, this ranks among the more significant negative patterns in our database. Over 8 matches, Carlisle has won 20 percentage points fewer games than expected. For bettors and fantasy managers, this historical trend suggests extra caution when S Mather is appointed.
The Bias Meter™
Match History
8 matches under this referee
| Date | Opponent | Score | Result | Cards | Division |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Oct 2025 | Hartlepool(H) | 3 - 1 | WIN | Carlisle: — Hartlepool: — | National League |
| 3 May 2025 | Salford(H) | 2 - 2 | DRAW | Carlisle: 🟨 2 Salford: — | League Two |
| 1 Jan 2025 | Crewe(A) | 2 - 3 | LOSS | Carlisle: 🟨 4 Crewe: 🟨 3 | League Two |
| 31 Aug 2024 | Tranmere(H) | 1 - 2 | LOSS | Carlisle: 🟨 2 Tranmere: — | League Two |
| 16 Mar 2024 | Shrewsbury(A) | 0 - 1 | LOSS | Carlisle: 🟨 2 Shrewsbury: 🟨 1 | League One |
| 27 Sept 2022 | Grimsby(A) | 2 - 1 | WIN | Carlisle: 🟨 2 Grimsby: 🟨 1 | League Two |
| 1 Feb 2022 | Salford(A) | 1 - 2 | LOSS | Carlisle: 🟨 2 Salford: — | League Two |
| 25 Sept 2021 | Sutton(A) | 0 - 4 | LOSS | Carlisle: 🟨 1🟥 1 Sutton: 🟨 1 | League Two |
When S Mather officiates Carlisle matches, the statistics reveal a severe negative pattern. Based on 8 matches spanning multiple seasons, our comprehensive analysis shows Carlisle achieves a 25% win rate under S Mather, compared to the 45% baseline expected for teams at this level. This negative 20.0 percentage point difference suggests a meaningful pattern worth examining. The data includes detailed card statistics, match outcomes, and historical trends to provide football fans, bettors, and analysts with evidence-based insights into this referee-team dynamic.
Frequently Asked Questions
Detailed Statistics
Cards for Carlisle
Cards for Opponents
Share This Analysis
Think your mates need to see this? Share the evidence.