🧑⚖️ Referee Analysis⚠️ BIAS DETECTED
M HalseyvsEverton
Analysis based on 36 matches since 2000
* Note: Detailed card statistics for matches before 2005 may be incomplete.
12
Wins
10
Draws
14
Losses
When M Halsey officiates Everton matches, the statistics reveal a notable negative pattern. Based on 36 matches spanning multiple seasons, our comprehensive analysis shows Everton achieves a 33.3% win rate under M Halsey, compared to the 45% baseline expected for teams at this level. This negative 11.7 percentage point difference suggests a meaningful pattern worth examining. The data includes detailed card statistics, match outcomes, and historical trends to provide football fans, bettors, and analysts with evidence-based insights into this referee-team dynamic.
⚠️POTENTIAL BIAS
⚠️ POTENTIAL BIAS DETECTED
This team performs notably worse under this referee compared to their overall average.
Bias Score
-11.7%
Matches Analyzed
36
The Bias Meter™
Bias Level-11.7%
Bias AgainstNeutralFavorable
Match History
36 matches under this referee
| Date | Opponent | Score | Result | Cards | Division |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 Feb 2013 | Man United(A) | 0 - 2 | LOSS | Everton: 🟨 2 Man United: — | Premier League |
| 15 Dec 2012 | Stoke(A) | 1 - 1 | DRAW | Everton: — Stoke: 🟨 1 | Premier League |
| 10 Mar 2012 | Tottenham(H) | 1 - 0 | WIN | Everton: 🟨 2 Tottenham: 🟨 2 | Premier League |
| 21 Jan 2012 | Blackburn(H) | 1 - 1 | DRAW | Everton: 🟨 2 Blackburn: 🟨 2 | Premier League |
| 29 Oct 2011 | Man United(H) | 0 - 1 | LOSS | Everton: 🟨 3 Man United: — | Premier League |
| 15 Aug 2009 | Arsenal(H) | 1 - 6 | LOSS | Everton: — Arsenal: — | Premier League |
| 22 Apr 2009 | Chelsea(A) | 0 - 0 | DRAW | Everton: 🟨 1 Chelsea: — | Premier League |
| 31 Jan 2009 | Man United(A) | 0 - 1 | LOSS | Everton: — Man United: — | Premier League |
| 13 Dec 2008 | Man City(A) | 1 - 0 | WIN | Everton: 🟨 1 Man City: — | Premier League |
| 8 Nov 2008 | West Ham(A) | 3 - 1 | WIN | Everton: 🟨 1 West Ham: 🟨 1 | Premier League |
| 30 Aug 2008 | Portsmouth(H) | 0 - 3 | LOSS | Everton: 🟨 1 Portsmouth: — | Premier League |
| 22 Mar 2008 | West Ham(H) | 1 - 1 | DRAW | Everton: — West Ham: — | Premier League |
| 9 Feb 2008 | Reading(H) | 1 - 0 | WIN | Everton: — Reading: — | Premier League |
| 12 Jan 2008 | Man City(H) | 1 - 0 | WIN | Everton: 🟨 2 Man City: 🟨 1 | Premier League |
| 14 Aug 2007 | Tottenham(A) | 3 - 1 | WIN | Everton: — Tottenham: 🟨 2 | Premier League |
| 13 May 2007 | Chelsea(A) | 1 - 1 | DRAW | Everton: 🟨 1 Chelsea: 🟨 2 | Premier League |
| 15 Apr 2007 | Charlton(H) | 2 - 1 | WIN | Everton: — Charlton: 🟨 3 | Premier League |
| 17 Dec 2006 | Chelsea(H) | 2 - 3 | LOSS | Everton: 🟨 1 Chelsea: 🟨 1 | Premier League |
| 29 Nov 2006 | Man United(A) | 0 - 3 | LOSS | Everton: 🟨 1 Man United: 🟨 1 | Premier League |
| 14 Oct 2006 | Middlesbrough(A) | 1 - 2 | LOSS | Everton: — Middlesbrough: 🟨 1 | Premier League |
| 26 Aug 2006 | Tottenham(A) | 2 - 0 | WIN | Everton: 🟨 1🟥 1 Tottenham: 🟨 1 | Premier League |
| 22 Apr 2006 | Birmingham(H) | 0 - 0 | DRAW | Everton: — Birmingham: 🟨 4 | Premier League |
| 1 Apr 2006 | Sunderland(H) | 2 - 2 | DRAW | Everton: — Sunderland: — | Premier League |
| 3 Dec 2005 | Blackburn(A) | 2 - 0 | WIN | Everton: 🟨 1 Blackburn: 🟨 1🟥 1 | Premier League |
| 2 Oct 2005 | Man City(A) | 0 - 2 | LOSS | Everton: — Man City: 🟨 1 | Premier League |
| 18 Dec 2004 | Blackburn(A) | 0 - 0 | DRAW | Everton: 🟨 2 Blackburn: 🟨 1 | Premier League |
| 11 Feb 2004 | Birmingham(A) | 0 - 3 | LOSS | Everton: — Birmingham: 🟨 1 | Premier League |
| 16 Aug 2003 | Arsenal(A) | 1 - 2 | LOSS | Everton: 🟨 3🟥 1 Arsenal: 🟨 1🟥 1 | Premier League |
| 15 Mar 2003 | West Ham(H) | 0 - 0 | DRAW | Everton: 🟨 2 West Ham: — | Premier League |
| 1 Feb 2003 | Leeds(H) | 2 - 0 | WIN | Everton: — Leeds: 🟨 1 | Premier League |
| 1 Dec 2002 | Newcastle(A) | 1 - 2 | LOSS | Everton: 🟨 1🟥 1 Newcastle: — | Premier League |
| 11 May 2002 | Arsenal(A) | 3 - 4 | LOSS | Everton: — Arsenal: — | Premier League |
| 20 Apr 2002 | Southampton(A) | 1 - 0 | WIN | Everton: — Southampton: 🟨 2 | Premier League |
| 18 Nov 2001 | Chelsea(H) | 0 - 0 | DRAW | Everton: 🟨 1 Chelsea: 🟨 3 | Premier League |
| 17 Mar 2001 | Southampton(A) | 0 - 1 | LOSS | Everton: 🟨 1 Southampton: 🟨 1 | Premier League |
| 21 Oct 2000 | Newcastle(A) | 1 - 0 | WIN | Everton: 🟨 3 Newcastle: 🟨 1 | Premier League |
10 Feb 2013
Man United (A)
Premier League
LOSS
0 - 2
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
🟨 2
Man United:
—
15 Dec 2012
Stoke (A)
Premier League
DRAW
1 - 1
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
—
Stoke:
🟨 1
10 Mar 2012
Tottenham (H)
Premier League
WIN
1 - 0
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
🟨 2
Tottenham:
🟨 2
21 Jan 2012
Blackburn (H)
Premier League
DRAW
1 - 1
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
🟨 2
Blackburn:
🟨 2
29 Oct 2011
Man United (H)
Premier League
LOSS
0 - 1
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
🟨 3
Man United:
—
15 Aug 2009
Arsenal (H)
Premier League
LOSS
1 - 6
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
—
Arsenal:
—
22 Apr 2009
Chelsea (A)
Premier League
DRAW
0 - 0
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
🟨 1
Chelsea:
—
31 Jan 2009
Man United (A)
Premier League
LOSS
0 - 1
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
—
Man United:
—
13 Dec 2008
Man City (A)
Premier League
WIN
1 - 0
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
🟨 1
Man City:
—
8 Nov 2008
West Ham (A)
Premier League
WIN
3 - 1
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
🟨 1
West Ham:
🟨 1
30 Aug 2008
Portsmouth (H)
Premier League
LOSS
0 - 3
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
🟨 1
Portsmouth:
—
22 Mar 2008
West Ham (H)
Premier League
DRAW
1 - 1
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
—
West Ham:
—
9 Feb 2008
Reading (H)
Premier League
WIN
1 - 0
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
—
Reading:
—
12 Jan 2008
Man City (H)
Premier League
WIN
1 - 0
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
🟨 2
Man City:
🟨 1
14 Aug 2007
Tottenham (A)
Premier League
WIN
3 - 1
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
—
Tottenham:
🟨 2
13 May 2007
Chelsea (A)
Premier League
DRAW
1 - 1
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
🟨 1
Chelsea:
🟨 2
15 Apr 2007
Charlton (H)
Premier League
WIN
2 - 1
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
—
Charlton:
🟨 3
17 Dec 2006
Chelsea (H)
Premier League
LOSS
2 - 3
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
🟨 1
Chelsea:
🟨 1
29 Nov 2006
Man United (A)
Premier League
LOSS
0 - 3
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
🟨 1
Man United:
🟨 1
14 Oct 2006
Middlesbrough (A)
Premier League
LOSS
1 - 2
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
—
Middlesbrough:
🟨 1
26 Aug 2006
Tottenham (A)
Premier League
WIN
2 - 0
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
🟨 1🟥 1
Tottenham:
🟨 1
22 Apr 2006
Birmingham (H)
Premier League
DRAW
0 - 0
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
—
Birmingham:
🟨 4
1 Apr 2006
Sunderland (H)
Premier League
DRAW
2 - 2
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
—
Sunderland:
—
3 Dec 2005
Blackburn (A)
Premier League
WIN
2 - 0
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
🟨 1
Blackburn:
🟨 1🟥 1
2 Oct 2005
Man City (A)
Premier League
LOSS
0 - 2
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
—
Man City:
🟨 1
18 Dec 2004
Blackburn (A)
Premier League
DRAW
0 - 0
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
🟨 2
Blackburn:
🟨 1
11 Feb 2004
Birmingham (A)
Premier League
LOSS
0 - 3
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
—
Birmingham:
🟨 1
16 Aug 2003
Arsenal (A)
Premier League
LOSS
1 - 2
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
🟨 3🟥 1
Arsenal:
🟨 1🟥 1
15 Mar 2003
West Ham (H)
Premier League
DRAW
0 - 0
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
🟨 2
West Ham:
—
1 Feb 2003
Leeds (H)
Premier League
WIN
2 - 0
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
—
Leeds:
🟨 1
1 Dec 2002
Newcastle (A)
Premier League
LOSS
1 - 2
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
🟨 1🟥 1
Newcastle:
—
11 May 2002
Arsenal (A)
Premier League
LOSS
3 - 4
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
—
Arsenal:
—
20 Apr 2002
Southampton (A)
Premier League
WIN
1 - 0
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
—
Southampton:
🟨 2
18 Nov 2001
Chelsea (H)
Premier League
DRAW
0 - 0
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
🟨 1
Chelsea:
🟨 3
17 Mar 2001
Southampton (A)
Premier League
LOSS
0 - 1
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
🟨 1
Southampton:
🟨 1
21 Oct 2000
Newcastle (A)
Premier League
WIN
1 - 0
Cards Awarded:
Everton:
🟨 3
Newcastle:
🟨 1
When M Halsey officiates Everton matches, the statistics reveal a notable negative pattern. Based on 36 matches spanning multiple seasons, our comprehensive analysis shows Everton achieves a 33.3% win rate under M Halsey, compared to the 45% baseline expected for teams at this level. This negative 11.7 percentage point difference suggests a meaningful pattern worth examining. The data includes detailed card statistics, match outcomes, and historical trends to provide football fans, bettors, and analysts with evidence-based insights into this referee-team dynamic.
Frequently Asked Questions
Detailed Statistics
Win Rate (Under Ref)33.3%
Baseline Win Rate45%
Bias Score-11.7%
Cards for Everton
🟨 Yellows / Game0.92
🟥 Reds / Game0.08
Cards for Opponents
🟨 Opp Yellows / Game0.97
🟥 Opp Reds / Game0.06
Share This Analysis
Think your mates need to see this? Share the evidence.